Why Would a Therapist Join Your Group Practice? Knowing the Value You Offer

There's a question a lot of new group practice owners ask themselves quietly, usually late at night or right after an associate gives notice... "Why would anyone stay with me when they could keep 100% of their fees on their own?"

I understand why you might ask this question…and also want to help you stop asking it and step into confidence about who you are and what you offer.

There are platforms and some group practices that promise therapists a higher split that you know you can afford, coaches who teach clinicians to go solo, and plenty of online conversations about owners "taking a huge cut of my fee." If you've spent any time in those spaces, it's easy to wonder if your split is something you need to apologize for.

I want to offer a different way of looking at it, because how you answer this question shapes so much about how you lead your team.

I Tried Going Solo, and I Hated It

When I was in my master's program, I knew I wanted to work in a group practice. I started out in one, and when that didn't work out, I went into private practice on my own. I hated it. Being in an office by myself, handling everything alone with nobody down the hall to talk to... it didn't work for me at all. That experience is a big part of why I went on to build group practices of my own.

So when I hear owners wonder why someone would choose a group practice, I think back to that version of me. Some therapists love solo practice, and that's great. Many others are looking for exactly what a well-run group practice offers.  They don’t want to do “this” alone, or they aren’t administrative in nature…or they just don’t want to bother with all of the things about business that excite you!

I've written about this from the therapist's side in Why Join a Group Practice? A Canadian Therapist's Perspective. This post is for you, the owner.

You're Providing a Service

Here's the mindset shift I want you to sit with. When an associate joins your practice, they're not doing you a favour, and you're not doing them one either. You're providing a service that they value, and the split is how they pay for it.

Therapists chatting together in the shared kitchen of a group practice office

Michael Gerber wrote about the difference between the technician, who does the work, and the entrepreneur, who builds the business that supports the work.¹ Most of us started as technicians... skilled clinicians who loved the work. When you became an owner, you took on a different job.

You built something that makes it easier for other clinicians to do their best work, and that has value.

If you don't believe that, you'll feel it every time the split comes up. You'll hesitate in interviews, you'll over-explain, and you'll try to make up for it by giving more and more until you burn out.

What You Offer Associates

Most owners undersell what they provide, because so much of it becomes invisible once it's working. Take a look at this list and notice how much of it is already true in your practice:

•      A steady flow of referrals from your website, your reputation and the marketing you pay for.

•      Admin support for intake, booking, billing and all the client questions that never stop coming.

•      Space and systems, including the office, the practice management software, secure communication and the policies that keep it all running.

•      Community, so they have colleagues to consult with and don't feel alone with hard cases.

•      Professional growth through case consultation and leadership that helps them develop.

•      Time back, because every hour they don't spend on business tasks is an hour they can spend with clients or on their own lives.

Daniel Pink's work points to autonomy, mastery and purpose as the things that motivate people most.² A good group practice can offer all three. It gives clinicians room to work their own way, support to keep getting better, and a shared purpose that's bigger than any one caseload.

Putting a Dollar Value on It

This is where things start to feel different. Sit down and estimate what it would cost a clinician to recreate what you offer on their own. Think about rent, practice management software, a website and hosting, directory listings and other marketing, bookkeeping, and any admin help they'd need to hire.

Then add the cost of their time. If a therapist spends five hours a week on admin and marketing, and their session fee is $160, that's $800 a week in sessions they could have seen instead. Over a year, that adds up quickly.

You don't need a perfect number. The point is to see, in black and white, that your split isn't money for nothing. It's payment for something that would cost them time, money and energy to build themselves.

What Canadian Associates Tend to Value

A lot of the advice out there about attracting therapists comes from the US, where insurance credentialing and billing are a huge part of what a group practice offers. Our landscape is different. Most Canadian group practices work with contractors, clients often pay directly and claim through their extended health benefits, and registration and regulation vary from province to province. That means the things your associates value most might be a steady stream of referrals, help with direct billing, a professional space, and colleagues who understand the work. It's worth asking them rather than assuming.

If I were a therapist looking at my practice from the outside, what would I be glad to pay for?

A Scenario You Might Recognize

Picture an owner interviewing a promising therapist. When the conversation turns to compensation, she rushes through the split and adds, "I know it's a lot, but..." The candidate picks up on her discomfort and starts to wonder whether the split is fair.

After doing the exercise above, the same owner walks into her next interview differently. She explains the split by walking through what's included and what it would cost to build alone. She isn't defensive. She's describing a service she believes in, and the candidates who are a good fit can hear the difference.

How to Get Clear on Your Value

If you want to try this in your own practice, here's where to start:

  • List everything you provide, including the things you've stopped noticing.

  • Estimate what it would cost a clinician to do it alone, in money and in time.

  • Ask your current associates what they value most about working with you. Their answers may surprise you.

  • Write a short value statement you can use in job postings, interviews and onboarding.

  • Revisit your split regularly so it reflects both what you offer and what it costs you to deliver.

Final Thoughts

When you know the value of what you offer, you stop apologizing for it. You can talk about compensation with confidence, attract the people who want what you've built, and let go of the idea that you have to keep giving more to justify your place in your own business.

If you'd like to go deeper on your numbers, including what it costs to deliver, how to think about splits and how to make sure you're paid properly too, that's what we work on together in The Numbers Room. And if you're not sure where to start, you can always book a free 15-minute call and we'll figure it out together.


References

1.     Michael E. Gerber, The E-Myth Revisited (HarperBusiness, 1995)

2.     Daniel H. Pink, Drive (Riverhead Books, 2009)

Next
Next

Why Everyone Still Wants to See the Owner: Rebuilding Your Group Practice Website So Your Team Gets Booked